As pet parents, taking the very best care of our fur babies is a chief concern. Many dog owners are often concerned about whether or not to crate their new puppy, and many experienced owners extol the virtues of crating a canine companion. However, for many that are new to dog ownership, choosing a dog enclosure is a tough job. There are many options available, and dog parents are often confused as to how to choose the best option for their furry pal. Common dilemma: puppy pen vs crate.
Dog enclosures are wonderful tools for providing both comfort and safety for dogs as well as for prohibiting problematic behavior, including potty accidents and chewing. Have no fear, though—various types of dog enclosures, including dog crates or puppy playpens, can be used to contain dogs at night or while pet parents are away at work.
Both have particular benefits, but choosing which enclosure is best for your furry friend is often a tough choice. The first step to selecting the right dog enclosure is understanding the differences between each type of enclosure. Knowing what is best for your dog’s needs will assist you in choosing the one that fits your pup’s particular needs.
What’s the Chief Difference between a Dog Pen and a Dog Crate?
Frankly, the major differences between these two dog containment systems are size and design.
A dog crate can be described as a box-shaped enclosure that may be made from wire or from plastic. The crate may be fashioned from wire (which dogs love because they can see much better while inside), or it may be made from durable plastic. When selecting the best dog crate for Fido, make sure it’s large enough for your furry pal to walk inside, turn around and stretch out while napping. You’ll also need to measure to make sure that your dog can easily lie down while inside the crate.
A dog pen is closer in design to a child’s playpen than a dog crate. The dog pen works well for almost all dog breeds, but, if you happen to own a giant breed, such as the Great Dane, you’ll want to make sure to choose a pen that is large enough for Fido. Most dog pens don’t have a top, so it is important to make sure the pen is the right height for your dog. Sometimes, this is also called a dog exercise pen or a puppy playpen.
The best puppy playpen is a great enclosure for the dog if you are home with her. This enclosure also works well with puppies to prevent housebreaking accidents. However, the crate offers longer-term enclosure needs than a pen, particularly if you are away at work for several hours each day.
Dogs that have been crate trained usually see the crate as their place in a shared space with their family. Once a dog becomes comfortable after a successful crate training, you may notice that she goes there to nap and rest. If your dog suffers from separation anxiety, you may notice that he feels more secure inside the crate. Many pet parents have enough room in the crate for a food and water bowl as well as a favorite blanket. This makes the crate feel like the dog’s “home space,” and they come to enjoy the security the crate provides .
What if I Plan to Confine My Dog for Several Hours Each Day?
For us pet parents, confining our dogs for four or more hours each day seems a little inhumane. Our dogs are meant to run and play, not sit in an enclosure for hours on end. However, some dogs develop separation anxiety while their family is gone to school or work, and, although it may be difficult to believe, these dogs actually prefer being confined while their family is away from home.
It’s important to make sure that your dog can change position regularly. This is why it is important to make sure that the dog enclosure is big enough for your dog to stand up, turn around, and stretch out while lying down.
Some pet parents believe the dog pen is better for dogs who will be confined for more than three hours each day. However, if you do choose to crate Fido, be sure that he has room to move around and change position in the crate.
Smaller dogs will do better in a dog pen than larger dogs for this reason. Plus, they can’t jump over the open top of the dog pen as a larger dog might. You can also place puppy training pads, their water and food bowl, and a few dog toys inside the dog pen so that Fido is happy and occupied while enclosed.
Restricting Access at Home
Instead of puppy-proofing one’s home, pet parents can set up a dog pen. This allows you and your dog to be in different places within the home without much advance preparation. This is also a good idea if you have elderly family or neighbors in your home and you are concerned your dog might accidentally knock them down.
During What Times is a Crate More Useful?
You may need to place your dog in a crate if he has a medical procedure done. It helps when a dog is already crate trained should she need to go through crate rest.
Also, dogs who crate well usually feel less stressed when kenneled during visits to the groomer or the vet. The Diggs Revol dog crate is perfect for this purpose.
You can use the dog crate as an overnight sleeping area for your dog. Since dogs don’t need to move around as much while sleeping, they can spend the entire night in a crate.
Crates can Assist in Housebreaking
A dog crate is an excellent housebreaking or potty training confinement zone since most dogs naturally will refrain from using the bathroom in a crate. Just be sure to use the right size dog crate, and take the dog out to potty often enough, usually once per hour depending upon the age of the dog.
1. Is a puppy pen better than a crate?
The answer really depends on what you plan to do with your dog. Each product has its own particular uses. Some pet parents prefer their dogs to use a crate, while others like the puppy pen.
2. Are puppy pens a good idea?
They are definitely a good idea for keeping your dog safe, and they can help to protect your floors when puppies are small and can’t control their bladders just yet.