Our Favorite: BarkBox
Why We Choose It:
- Theme-based yet customizable boxes.
- Mostly arrives within 5 days.
- More than $45 worth of toys and treats.
As pet parents, providing for our pups is one of our chief responsibilities. We purchase any number of products for our furry pals, including chew toys, dog treats, dog food, and even clothing! However, purchasing these things can be expensive when we buy them one by one. With a dog subscription, pet parents get the opportunity to try and keep a number of products at a much cheaper price than what we would pay for these products when buying individually. Most dog subscriptions allow for consumers to return products if not satisfied, and many of these subscriptions allow customers to “customize” the box so that you get just the right products for your precious pooch.
The Best Dog Subscription Box in 2022
Although most pet parents have heard of the most popular subscription services due to advertising or word of mouth, there are actually a wealth of dog subscription services that are great but less well-known. We’d like to present a great list of dog subscription services, detail some of their products, and recommend our favorites. Our top dog subscription box is the BarkBox subscription service.
Our Favorite: BarkBox
- Affordable, varied subscription prices based on what you request
- Periodic deliveries are based on a theme (for example, Scooby-Doo)
- The Super Chewer box offers “impossible to destroy” toys
- 100 percent money-back guarantee
- Monthly subscription may be canceled, but not the six-month plan or the yearly plan
- BarkBox offers ONLY treats and toys, not food or other pet products.
BarkBox is not only one of the most well-known dog subscriptions, but it is also well-liked by pet parents. Plus, the subscription CAN save you money if you regularly purchase dog toys and treats for your pup. In fact, some subscriptions can save up to $10 per month!
The products in BarkBox are made without using wheat, corn, or soy, so dogs with sensitive tummies or allergies need not worry about their consumption of the product. However, you will be asked if your dog has allergies or food sensitivities so that the box is packed with products that fit your pup.
It’s important to understand that BarkBox does NOT offer food, clothing, or other dog products such as leashes. Plus, should you decide that you no longer wish to subscribe, you can ONLY cancel if you are doing a month-to-month subscription. The six-month and twelve-month subscriptions are paid upfront, and they are not eligible for cancellation.
Best Quarterly Subscription: BoxDog
- Four types of handmade doggie treats in each subscription as well as pet products
- Handmade doggie treats include cookies and chews; they are human-grade food, too
- Pet parents will get two or three “premium” products based on filling out the questionnaire for Fido
- Dog products do include clothing or toys as well as a vegan skincare item
- Delivery is only four times each year
- There is a build-your-own-box option, but prices aren’t listed
BoxDog offers both a regular and a grain-free dog food options for pups with allergies or digestion issues. Each quarter, pet parents will receive four handmade treats, such as doggie cookies. You’ll also get a certain amount of toys or chews, or you may choose a clothing item, gear (such as leashes), or extra treats.
BoxDog does offer a monthly subscription box, but it may be more costly than other dog subscription boxes. In fact, a quarterly box that offers two extra premium items is $39.99 per quarter, while the quarterly box that offers three extra premium items is $49.99. Frankly, pet parents who won’t be spending $200 per year on pet toys, treats, clothing, and gear will be spending too much. However, if you enjoy spoiling your furry pal, the BoxDog quarterly subscription could be right for you.
Speaking of monthly offerings, the monthly cost of a build your own box is unknown; it will be based on the products a pet parent chooses, which might actually be cheaper than the quarterly boxes.
Best Budget Box: PoochPerks
- Great for pet parents on a budget
- May be upgraded if you wish
- Pet parents may request more durable toys for dogs that love to chew
- Low introductory price for pet parents on a budget
- Customer service may be unresponsive
- Cancellation issues
This cute box will deliver your pet toys, treats, and accessories made in the United States for less than you might spend at the local pet store. Plus, knowing a monthly subscription box is coming into your home could help to curb impulse buying for Fido. You will share your pet’s preferences and dietary needs, if applicable, before shipping and sign up for gift boxes for Fido’s birthday or holidays. The ability to procure these extra holiday and birthday boxes can maximize your savings on pet products.
The PoochPerks subscription starts at $19 per month, but pet parents do have the ability to upgrade as needed or desired. Some pet parents did express issues with cancellation policies or returns, which is one of the few detriments to the subscription of the Poochperks box.
For a Good Cause: RescueBox
Unlike most other subscription services that are focused on gimmicks, RescueBox is focused on creating a high-quality set that will be more than enough for your pet to play with for a month. Also, they help dogs in pet shelters across the United States be vaccinated and adequately stocked with food.
So far, Rescue Box has donated more than fifty million pounds of dog food to various shelters, helping thousands of dogs gain their strength before they are adopted and taken care of properly, with all the love and compassion that they deserve.
Also, RescueBox will provide all of their customers with offers on how to save on other purchases, as well as options and contacts in the case that they are willing to help canine charities that were proven to do good work.
Inside each RescueBox package, you will receive several high-quality delicacies, including chewing treats and rewards treats. Things like smoked pig ears or large marrow bones are very common, and if you have a dog that likes to work its teeth on such savory goodies, you will make that dog very happy. Most of the products will be made in the USA, which will be noted on the packaging, with the rest being made in Canada or Mexico. There are no products in this box that are made in developing nations or are shipped overseas to reduce prices.
All of the treats and edibles are USDA approved and are tested to be safe for your pooch regardless of the breed and age. Additionally, with each monthly box, you will receive an offer for various products, either for your dog or for yourself, making you save a bit more while still helping dogs around the country.
Sadly, there is no customization option to receive different boxes depending on the dog’s size and breed, which means that you will need to be careful not to give toys that are too small to your large pets, or very large toys to small breeds that will be unable to play with them. For products that are of inadequate size for your pooch, you can store all of the products and bring them to the dog shelter at some point.
Highly Personalized for your Pup: PupBox
- Offers more than simply toys and treats
- Perfect for those who love spoiling their precious pups, but don’t have a store nearby or have time to browse in-store
- Backed by Petco, so you’re likely to get some of the products you’d find in-store at a cheaper price
- Subscribers must provide a credit card (or debit card) upon signing up
- Some customers did not like the cancellation process or the refund policy
PupBox is a subscription service that sends you toys, treats, and other goodies for your dog every month. You sign up and give them your credit card information, and every month, you’ll get a new PupBox in the mail.
You start by filling out a questionnaire about your dog, including their age, breed, likes, dislikes, etc. The manufacturer uses this to customize a box especially for your dog, although every shipment includes at least one toy, treats or chews, a training aid, and an accessory of some sort.
The service is geared toward people who want to spoil their dogs, as well as those who can’t go to the pet store as often as they’d like to get gear for their pups.
As you might expect, though, the company charges a premium for the convenience, and you’ll likely end up paying more for the stuff than you would if you bought it all individually. Also, you’ll likely get a few things that you wouldn’t have bought yourself, which can be both a good and bad thing.
The company actually started on the popular TV show “Shark Tank,” although they’ve since been bought by Petco. PupBox is one of the most popular dogs subscription boxes in the world today, although there’s little that differentiates them from the others.
With Pet Parents in Mind: Dog Mom Box
- Offers products not just for Fido, but for pet parents too
- Supports small business, so some products may be locally sourced
- Each box comes with at least five items, but as many as seven
- Considers both pet parents and pets in an effort to enrich your lives and make life better for Fido
- Doesn’t seem to provide toys for super chewers
- Not all items may be beneficial for you or your dog
Dog Mom Box is a subscription that offers something not only for your dog but for you as well (some can be customized as Dog Dad boxes, too). The company states that they try to support local small businesses when possible, so many of their items may be locally sourced. While this is a noble idea, you may not get the same items ever again. This could be a problem if Fido really enjoys a particular product that can’t be replaced should he chew it or finish the bag of treats.
While it’s great to offer a dog subscription box that offers “dog mom swag,” pet parents should weigh whether or not they truly need these products. Pet parents may be better suited to a dog subscription box that caters more to Fido and his specific needs in order to meet one’s budget.
For Dogs that Love to Chew: Bullymake
- Tough toys that are intended to satisfy even the most robust of chewers
- Offers a variety of products including toys
- Company will send a replacement toy if your super chewer does happen to destroy it
- Company will send toys to fit multiple dog preferences, such as tugging and fetching
- A bit pricey
- Is a toy and treat box exclusively, not for products, food, or gear
Bullymake may be able to save pet parents money by offering them highly durable, indestructible dog toys that intense chewers love. The makers of the Bullymake subscription box created their subscription with aggressive chewers in mind, and they will replace any toy that your dog destroys within the month (between boxes); all you need to do is contact customer service and request it! You will have to provide a photo of the destroyed product, however.
Bullymake IS one of the more expensive dogs subscription boxes, but, the toys included could save pet parents money over time. The monthly subscription rate is $45. However, pet parents may opt for a three-month plan that costs $36 per month, and there is a six-month bundle that is estimated to be about $34 per month. There is a twelve-month package that is about $31 per month. Cancellation policies for these plans may vary, so pet parents need to inquire when signing up.
Best Organic and Closest to Homemade Diet: The Farmer’s Dog
- Made with no preservatives or fillers
- Recipes designed by board-certified veterinary nutritionists
- Compliance with the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) standards
- Customizable plans based on pet’s needs
- Made in the USA
- Auto-shipping available
- Limited protein options, especially for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities
- Bags are not resealable
- Perishable and requires refrigeration or deep freeze
- More expensive compared to traditional dog food options
First, some grim facts and figures on why it’s important to know what your pooch’s food contains. According to a study by VCA Animal Hospital, 80 percent of pets older than three years of age have active dental disease . Nearly 60 percent of the dogs in the United States are either obese or overweight. Plus, a great number of dogs experience allergies or skin reactions based upon the ingredients in their food.
According to The Farmer’s Dog, keeping one’s dog healthy starts with feeding them right.
Numerous studies have found that pet foods often contain ingredients that are not listed on their labels or missing those they claim to use. Pet food production in the United States is carried out at surprisingly low safety and quality standards, which are hidden behind loose labeling and marketing regulations. This is because pet food is considered “feed grade,” and its production is not held to the same standards as human food.
Meal – Powders like ‘Chicken Meal’ can contain meat from sick livestock or from parts of the livestock we wouldn’t normally eat, but it’s ground down into a “meal” and then included in ingredients.
Label Tricks – Foods can hide behind misleading claims on the bag’s label. For example, “Made with beef” can mean just a small percentage of real beef.
In response, The Farmer’s Dog began manufacturing its lineup of fresh food, and they are among today’s best dog food delivery services. The brand does not make a lot of big claims. The website explicitly states there isn’t anything special about the purpose of The Farmer’s Dog products; they simply want to provide dogs with proper nutrition.
The Farmer’s Dog website claims: “It’s still dog food, just how it should be,” Many pet parents agree with this claim.
Best Dental Hygiene Box: BarkBright
- A great way to provide dental health products without having to brush Fido’s teeth
- Good for dogs that resist having their teeth brushed
- Pet parents should see results within one month of use
- Offers dental products exclusively, no toys, no food, no treats
If you have a dog that needs assistance with dental hygiene, the BarkBright may be the right product for you. In fact, if your dog hates having her teeth brushed, BarkBright has a great way of delivering dental health solutions while also offering a treat that dogs love.
Bark Bright uses a natural toothpaste that contains three enzymes proven to clean your dog’s teeth. Pet parents will coat the treat or chew with the toothpaste, and your dog will then let natural instincts and the natural enzymes do the rest.
Pet parents will get a box with all the supplies one will need to keep Fido’s teeth clean for one month, so you won’t have to worry about stretching products so that they’ll last until the next box comes.
Bark Bright products include dental chews and a special enzymatic dog toothpaste that is designed to clean your dog’s teeth without the need for brushing when used together.
Their subscription service provides you with enough supplies for one month of dental care for your dog and is based on your dog’s size. All products are delivered on a monthly basis to your door. Typically, a box costs between $30 and $35 per month. This may seem expensive at the onset, but pet parents can save money later by providing their dogs with good dental health throughout their lives.
Treats Only: Pet Treater Dog Pack
- Offers a pet toy or pet treat only package for dogs that may be on a special diet
- Only $15 per month, but the just treats or just toys options are about $18 per month
- Offers a Deluxe Dog Bundle for about $25 per month
- Pet parents can pay for a multiple-monthly subscription in advance in order to save money
- Not for dogs with allergies or other special diet needs, but does offer the option of just toys
Pet Treater is a subscription program that treats your pet every month with quality items that won’t break your wallet. In fact, the Pet Treater subscription offers one of the most cost-effective subscriptions of the choices in this review. Pet parents love the choices of toys, including stuffed animals, rope pulls, and other chew toys. Pet parents may opt for the Deluxe subscription option that is just $10 more per month but offers up to eight treats and toys. (There isn’t much information on how much more it would be to have this made as exclusively toys or exclusively treats like the basic box.)
If you are looking for a great way to discover new products for your dog every month, then Pet Treater is the perfect option, plus it’s relatively inexpensive.
With Pet Treater, you and your pooch will be sent a huge box of dog goodies including interactive dog toys, treats, grooming products, and even a little gift for you, the owner.
And best of all, all the treats are made in the USA.
To get started, all you need to do is answer a few questions about your pet (name, gender, breed, age, birthday), choose your plan, and your Pet Treater box will be on its way.
If You Love Dressing Your Dog: The Dapper Dog Box
- Great for pet parents who love dressing Fido
- Offers toys as well as clothing
- Free shipping
- Easy cancellation policy
- Pricey ($35 per month)
The Dapper Dog offers a bandana that’s based on a monthly theme, and you’ll get five full-sized items in each monthly subscription box. However, at $35 per month, you’ll need to weigh the pros and cons of the necessity of this box subscription.
The Dapper Dog subscription box sends you a monthly box of healthy treats, adorable toys, and a gorgeous, limited edition bandana available exclusively from Dapper Dog.
If you’ve got a fashion diva on your hands, keep your pooch’s closet well-stocked with a box that comes with a bandana in each one, in addition to natural treats and fun stuff that supports small and local businesses. This box also donates a portion of sales to help shelter dogs.
For the Health Conscious Dog Lover: WagWell Box
- Contains organic treats and all-natural bully sticks
- Promises healthiest and safest toys and treats
- More expensive than other subscriptions due to organic content
The WagWell Box is perfect for the dog lover who is also health-conscious. You’ll get all-natural bully sticks for dogs, so these may be beneficial to super chewers as well. However, this particular subscription is likely to be a little more expensive due to the organic ingredients.
Factors Considered In Reviewing The Best Dog Subscription Boxes
First, pet parents need to determine what their dog’s preferences are. Do you have a dog with allergies or food sensitivity? A dog subscription box can be of use to both you and Fido, as those that focus specifically on fresh dog food often offer customized food to fit your dog’s diet. Does your dog love to chew (read: shred) dog toys, the furniture, his dog bed? Most dog subscription boxes will allow pet parents to choose highly durable toys that aren’t easily destroyed. In fact, many pet parents say that the toys meant for super chewers last for not only the month between shipments but many last much longer.
Pet parents who prefer online shopping or who have odd working hours (those that don’t match the hours that a big box pet supply store might be in operation) will appreciate the ease with which they can get toys, treats, and even more gear via a dog subscription box.
The variety of products is also a consideration when reviewing the best dog subscription boxes. Some boxes offer only treats and toys, but others will allow pet parents to have doggie clothing, leashes, and other pet products delivered in their monthly subscription boxes. A few dog subscription box plans even have products for doggo moms and doggo dads!
So, when reviewing these products, it’s a good idea to determine what type of products are offered, the variety of the products, and why pet parents and their pups would benefit from subscribing to these dog box subscription programs.
Many of our favorite dog subscriptions also let owners customize the contents to make them perfectly tailored to your individual furry friend, so you can get the most out of every shipment. Others give you the option to tweak the delivery frequency, so you can skip or pause delivery depending on your personal budget and needs.
How much does a dog subscription box cost?
A dog subscription box’s cost will vary depending on the types of products you want for your pup, but the average price for most subscription boxes is around $30 per month, while the most expensive boxes can reach as high as $50 per month (some are $60 without coupons or promotions). The price depends on the type of surprise you want for your pup (treats or toys, for example) and how often you want a box delivered. Pet parents who know they will want the subscription box delivered every month for at least one year may be able to sign up for a subscription where you pay up-front, then you get a few extra dollars off the total of the subscription plan. However, be sure to read the fine print and make sure that you can cancel the yearly plan—some subscriptions do not allow for yearly or bi-yearly plans to be canceled until the subscription is up.
A dog subscription box is often cost-effective if you tend to get your dog treats and toys on a regular basis. Many companies charge less than pet store prices, for toys that are of great quality.
Best ways to get the most out of your dog subscription box
The best way to get the most out of your dog subscription box is to find one that offers the products your pup loves but allows you to customize the offerings in the box as well. When pet parents can customize the dog subscription box, you can get toys that fit your dog’s personality and preferences, and most dogs take to these toys and can get a lot of wear and tear out of them.
Dog subscription boxes come in all sizes to suit different pups’ preferences. Most shipments include a variety of products such as toys, treats, and chews. Many companies, such as BarkBox, allow you to customize what you want to receive every month, so you can opt for more toys or more treats if that’s what you and your pup prefer. Heavy chewers, dogs with allergies, or pups that don’t appear to really show interest in toys can all benefit from a dog subscription box.
While some dog subscription boxes only provide chews and treat, most come with a toy or two for each shipment. If your dog is mostly interested in toys, you can opt for a box specializing in dog toys such as Pet Treater Dog Box or Bullymake. These options are great for dogs that go through toys quickly, requiring frequent replacements, especially if they tend to chew.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which dog box is best to get?
If you want an affordable dog subscription box, consider BarkBox. One of the most popular membership boxes out there, BarkBox is all about themes. You and your pup are sure to be delighted by each month’s delivery.
From Scooby-Doo to Cinco de Mayo, the boxes come filled with two toys, two treats, and a chew designed to fit the theme. When you sign up, you will answer a few questions about your pup (weight, age, and possible allergies).
Three subscriptions are available: monthly ($35), six months ($30 per month), and 12 months (about $27 per month). Shipping is free within the contiguous United States, and BarkBox even has an online shop selling more toys and surprises.
If your pup likes to chew, you might want to opt for the Super Chewer box filled with impossible-to-destroy toys. You can cancel at any time on a month-to-month plan, but the other plans cannot be canceled.
If you are unhappy for any reason, BarkBox offers a 100% money-back guarantee, which takes the stress out of treating your dog.
Are dog subscriptions worth it?
If your dog loves toys, a subscription box is a great way to introduce new and engaging toys to your dog’s routine. Many subscription boxes have a theme each month, so expect to receive adorable toys that go along with the theme.
Is BarkBox or Bullymake better?
If your pet doesn’t love the toys and treats as much as you’d hoped, you might find that you don’t have quite as much room in your budget for a subscription box. In that case, consider cutting back to one box every other month or canceling altogether.
These days there are subscription boxes for almost every kind of pet, including dogs that are “super chewers.” In that case, the Bullymake dog subscription seems to be a better choice.
Barkbox offers a variety of items, typically treats and toys, and they do offer a preference for dogs that are described as chewers. However, Bullymake’s reviews show more customers satisfied with their highly durable products for those dogs that love to chew.
Both the Barkbox and the Bullymake dog box subscriptions are filled with naturally made products, and they may cost a little more. However, when purchasing the same types of products in-store, you’ll likely pay more.
Are Woof packs worth it?
The Woof pack subscription box offers Canadian-made treats and toys, and, while some subscribers were very happy with their monthly box, others were not. Some say that the toys weren’t durable, while others state that customer service at Woof pack is lacking. In fact, the automated renewal feature appears to be the prime negative regarding the Woof pack subscription.